“The Yellow Wallpaper” by Charlotte Gilman is not simply a story of a particular unfortunate female but a depiction of what can happen to anyone who lives in isolation and faces oppression. I share Moore’s view that the image of the woman is collective, for which reason she actually remains unnamed. I also agree that the narrator’s husband, John, performs as an abuser since he discounts the feelings of his wife systematically, trying to persuade the other that she is hysterical rather than ill.
Moore reviews the tactics of manipulation that John utilizes and adds the relative quotes, which I regard as powerful evidence. From my personal perspective, the strongest piece is the following. “If a physician of high standing, and one’s own husband, assures friends and relatives that there really is nothing the matter with one but temporary nervous depression—a slight hysterical tendency—what is one to do?” Moore cites this quotation to illustrate that John has absolute control over his wife, which marks the lack of boundaries in their relationship, and this is persuasive. It becomes apparent to the reader how suppressed the narrator is on a constant basis, having no possibility to express and defend her own opinion. The outside research on the topic is relevant as well since it contributes substantially to the trustworthiness of Moore’s analysis.
Actually, I consider the argumentation quite appropriate, as it is well-structured, relies on facts as well as logic, and nothing critical seems to be missing. Notably, the author proves each of her statements with qualitative as well as quantitative data and provides a sufficient amount of examples. The article under review is a good sample of an argumentative essay that, in my opinion, does not need any further improvement.