Introduction
AT&T is a leading telecommunication and technology company with a corporate mission of providing seamless connections among people to greater possibilities with inspiration, simplicity, and expertise. The company is a multinational founded in 1983, with its headquarters in Dallas, Texas (Feigenbaum & Gross, 2021). The company ranks third against its competitors in the telecommunication industry. The company has over 200,000 employees and over 25 offices in the United States (Shastri, 2022). The company provides various products, including telecommunications equipment, wireless communication, internet and broadband, managed networking, long and local-distance telephone services, and wholesale services.
AT&T is also involved in producing, developing, and distributing feature films, gaming, television, and content in digital and physical forms (Feigenbaum & Gross, 2021). The company serves business and individual customer enterprises. While delivering these services, AT&T has failed to maintain its customer support service up to the current and recommended professional standards, influencing its online rating and credibility.
Problem Analysis
One of the underlying issues that need to be solved at AT&T is customer care service. The company ranks fourth in customer service against its competitors (Fortune Staff, 2023). AT&T’s competitors include Windstream, Verizon, T-Mobile, Vodafone, and Frontier Communications (Shastri, 2022). AT&T comes first at gender, CEO, eNPS, and diversity ranks.
Still, it fails to outperform its competitor at product quality rank, NPS rank, pricing rank, and customer services, where the company positions fourth place in all categories (Fortune Staff, 2023). AT&T also has poor ratings as far as its customer service is concerned, where the company scores poorly on popular sites such as Trustpilot, Sitejabber, and Better Business Bureau, with a rating of 1.3, 1.7, and 1.1, respectively (Fortune Staff, 2023). This is clear evidence of just how poorly the firm performs in overall customer service, which is a critical issue for any top organization.
In all the sites, one significant theme is the poor customer service issue raised by its customers. Customer service also affects the product quality and services rendered by the company. Customer complaints range from poor after-sale service, incompetent customer service, extra charges that they consider unprofessional, late replies, and, to some extent, none.
Customers have also experienced situations where they have been rudely replied to on social media by the AT&T customer service representative. In Trustpilot, one customer describes AT&T customer support as a complete mess (The Home Security Advisor, 2022). The customer had to go through three different employees for their billing change. Another customer reported having to go through different people to have their service canceled (The Home Security Advisor, 2022). The process took three hours, which is considerably long for such service completion.
The available customer service representatives also do not feel appreciated in their workstations. Analysis from sites that rank employee satisfaction shows an average rating from Indeed, ConsumerAffairs, and Best Company, where the company has a score of 3.7 (Minsker, 2019). The customer service representatives report poor working conditions and workloads, which demotivates them (Minsker, 2019). They are not given the required attention and funding from the company, making them overwork under adverse conditions.
On the other hand, customers report misleading ads and dishonesty among AT&T employees, whom they offer and guide customers to make purchases they later regret. One customer wrote the waiver activation fee, which they were told was possible, only to realize that it was not after one week. Another customer says they received an offer to make trade-ins for a new iPhone only to realize that the offer was not free, as indicated in the ad when they visited the physical store (The Home Security Advisor, 2022). Customers also complain about higher bills; they say they are promised different situations every time they call customer service, but the case never changes.
Needed Change
As an executive manager at AT&T, the company needs to restructure its current customer service into a proper and existing customer service department with specific regional places where customers can visit to resolve their inquiries and problems. Decentralized service departments across various regions and states should unite to support a centralized department providing customer care and support services. Currently, the company has an interactive voice response (IVR) system (Bresnahan, 2021; Callaway & Sant’Anna, 2021). The system offers automated telephone pre-recorded messages by the company to engage with AT&T customers, which enables these customers to gain access to some available information without necessarily going through an agent (Cheng & Pan, 2021). While the service helps the company manage bulk responses, it does not offer the natural human connections a customer would experience if they were replied to with actual human customer care support.
Of all the 25 offices in various states where AT&T operates, only a number of them have a dedicated department for customer service. Employees are authorized to address customers’ inquiries and issues raised in the rest of the offices (Shapiro, 2021). As the executive manager, the change will involve implementing customer care services in all the departments, where several employees are assigned to handle complaints, inquiries, replies, and after-sales services. Each office must have a team leader responsible for coordinating customer support to ensure that responses are consistent and customer inquiries are handled as fast as possible. Each customer care service individual must be professional and have the required set minimum standard to act in such capacity on behalf of the head office and regional offices.
Steps to Change Implementation
The first step in implementing a physical customer service department in each regional location is to define the service team’s roles. The team will consist of contact center agents, a team leader, and supervisors. The contact center agents will be responsible for engaging with the customer through various channels such as the phone, email, chats, and social media platforms. Their job description will include but not be limited to engaging the customers, diagnosing the problem, if any, finding appropriate solutions, and responding to customers in a professional manner that leaves them satisfied and loyal to AT&T. The team leader will be responsible for the regional contact center, ensuring that the agents perform according to the company’s principles, respond within the stipulated time, and keep the agents motivated. The supervisor will receive direct customer complaints regarding center agents and address such concerns with the team leaders and management.
The second stage will involve customer service training provided for regional sales department representatives and the personnel set aside for the customer service department. This will include outsourcing from companies specializing in training customer service agents and employees since it will be more cost-effective than developing an internal program that might take time. The training will be conducted for three months for both the centralized and the decentralized branches, where the activity will run concurrently. This will be important to some employees who are incompetent in handling customer complaints and concerns. The company will proceed to set and communicate standards for customer service.
The third stage will involve a deep analysis of customer complaints and concerns and providing numerous channels through which customer can raise their concerns and receive feedback. Customer services should be a complete journey where customers get support, from buying the company’s product to after-sales and billing support. The data from customer complaints and concerns analysis should be stored and shared with the staff to build an information system where trends can be identified.
In addition to the channels for reaching the company, there will be three layers where the customer concerns will be channeled. To ensure the proper handling of cases, they must be first directed to the frontline staff. If the claim exceeds their jurisdiction, the frontline staff must be required to escalate the matter to their respective team leader and supervisor. This protocol is crucial for ensuring efficient and effective case resolution, and failure to adhere to it may result in unsatisfactory outcomes for all parties involved.
The last stage is to ensure the culture is spread to the other employees at a larger by introducing a customer-focused culture by doing follow-ups and holding employees accountable. AT&T is a customer-centered company whose activities should be directed toward exceptional customer satisfaction. Several steps must be taken to implement such a culture in the company. Certain job specifications will be restructured so that they incorporate customer service. Team members’ performance and customer experience consistency will be analyzed, and appropriate adjustments will be made to suit the customer experience.
Result of Implemented Change
The result of the restructuring of the customer service department is an increased response time to customer complaints, aftersales services, and concerns. There is an expectation that issues or inquiries channeled to the company through emails should be responded to within 24 hours of business operation time. This should also apply to social media platforms. SMS from customers should be responded to within ten minutes, and calls should be answered almost immediately when an agent is available. At the end of the implementation of change, the company must have a presence in virtually all the available social media platforms with a channel dedicated only to customer care service.
Employees are expected to master and know their mandate concerning the company’s cultural drive towards excellent customer support service. At the end of the process, they must be in a position to collaborate with the formed dedicated department of customer support service, the customers, and other stakeholders. The result of implementation must reflect on popular review sites where the ratings are expected to improve. Better customer service should also reflect in the increase in the profit margin experienced by the company from various regions.
Conclusion
This paper has analyzed AT&T by looking at its customer service aspect, which has recently received backlash for being one of the worst among its competitors. Due to the strict chain of command, the company has not given much attention to the customer service representatives. There are limited physical customer department services in their regional branches, where the company has adopted the IVR system to handle customer responses in most cases. The company’s online customer service response team does not respond in time, giving the customer enough attention. With improved customer service, the company can efficiently offer products and services such as aftersales services without customer complaints.
Summary of the Findings and Recommendations
AT&T is a leading telecommunication and technology company that has failed to satisfy its customers. Customers have complained about late and no replies if they engage the company through the mail. Complaints channeled through social media platforms have been received with occasional rude replies. AT&T has not sufficiently handled customer experience professionally and recommended standards ensuring they remain competitive.
Similarly, customers have complained of slow and poor after-sales services and misleading ads, leading to miscellaneous spending. This has led to a poor rating of AT&T customer service ratings in popular rating sites, affecting the company’s credibility and resulting in high customer turnover and low customer retention rates. AT&T’s customer service also ranks poorly, with an aggregated rating of 1.4 out of 5 from customer review sites.
A restructuring of the Department of Customer Services to be decentralized is beneficial for the company. The changes will involve having a dedicated customer service department in each regional branch comprised of center service agents, team leaders, and regional supervisors. The project will be implemented in four stages, including defining the service team roles, employee customer service training, analyzing customer complaints and concerns, providing numerous channels to raise their concerns and receive feedback, and doing follow-ups. The project results are improved customer service, reply time, and better after-sales services, which can translate to increased profit margin and customer retention.
Recommendations
Customer service runs concurrently with better and competitive product quality and pricing rank. AT&T ranks second in product quality and pricing categories compared to its competitors. From the analysis of the customer service situation of AT&T, there are two recommendations that this case study draws. First, the company should review and tailor its pricing based on its customers and regions to match its competitors. This will ensure that the company remains competitive and retain its customers. Secondly, the company should improve its product as it is one of the main reasons it receives customer complaints. After-sale services should be included in every product the company offers its customers.
References
Bresnahan, T. (2021). Artificial intelligence technologies and aggregate growth prospects. Prospects for Economic Growth in the United States, 132–170. Web.
Callaway, B., & Sant’Anna, P. H. (2021). Difference-in-differences with multiple time periods. Journal of Econometrics, 225(2), 200–230. Web.
Cheng, H. T., & Pan, Y. (2021). I am not a Chatbot: An empirical investigation of humanized profiles of social media customer service representatives. Web.
Feigenbaum, J. J., & Gross, D. P. (2021). Organizational frictions and increasing returns to automation: Lessons from AT&T in the Twentieth Century (No. w29580). National Bureau of Economic Research. Web.
Shapiro, C. (2021). Vertical mergers and input foreclosure lessons from the AT&T/Time Warner case. Review of Industrial Organization, 59(2), 303-341. Web.
Shastri, A. (2022). Dynamic SWOT analysis of AT&T – 2023 update. IIDE. Web.