Freedom and security are two essential elements of society but guaranteeing one is often associated with violating the other. Considering the threats that the US is facing, security appears vital to some. However, others argue that freedom is more important for the success of the nation. This paper aims to discuss two opposite views on which is more important: security or freedom, and provide examples of violations of both aspects.
specifically for you
for only $16.05 $11/page
Given the multidimensional nature of security that includes physical, economic, and political aspects, one should consider its importance for the nation. According to Farrell and Newman (2019), after the September 11 attacks, security in the US was taken to another level, and more protective measures were implemented in terms of border control and airport safety. Guaranteeing the citizens’ welfare should be a priority to prevent life losses and threats. On the other hand, an issue of personal information misuse arises as the technology develops, and more data is collected and stored by the government and various companies. Invading freedom can be considered a violation of human rights. Facebook – Cambridge Analytica scandal of 2018 is an example of an outrageous data breach that caused a big debate on personal information and freedom. In this regard, while the government should improve the nation’s security, the citizens’ liberty should not be taken away. I believe that freedom is fundamental and more enduring as there are always new threats arising that need to be dealt with.
To sum up, security is essential, but freedom is just as important for the nation’s thriving. While the government is tasked with providing a safe environment for the citizens, it should not abuse their fundamental rights. Doing the opposite and overusing the power the government upholds means betraying its essence of ensuring the nation’s well-being. Therefore, there is a need to find a balance between the two elements.
Farrell, H., & Newman, A. L. (2019). Of privacy and power: The transatlantic struggle over freedom and security. Princeton University Press.