Introduction
I am going to speak on the current problems in providing community mental health and addiction services to our Indigenous adolescents, adults, and families. The topic of this conference, “The Future of Indigenous Health Care in Ontario,” is of utmost significance, particularly in light of the problem of untreated mental illness among Indigenous people and the repercussions that stem from it. In today’s talk, I will delve into this issue, which has been referred to as a “mental health crisis” in the media and provides historical context as well as an overview of the current challenges that Indigenous communities face in terms of gaining access to mental health and addiction services. There have been some positive developments in recent years toward providing culturally safe care, which has shown promising results. Indigenous mental health and addiction services in Ontario have a convoluted history rooted in colonization and the loss of traditional healing traditions, but recent initiatives to provide culturally safe care have shown positive effects.
Historical Context
The long and complicated history of Indigenous peoples in Canada, which has its roots in colonization and the loss of traditional healing practices, has significantly impacted the mental health and well-being of Indigenous communities. This loss of traditional healing practices was a significant factor in the colonization of Indigenous peoples in Canada. The residential school system, which removed Indigenous children from their families and communities, was one of the most significant events in this history. As a result, Indigenous children lost their language, culture, and identity as a result of this (Pride et al., 2021). This traumatic experience and other colonial policies, such as forced relocation, have resulted in intergenerational trauma, contributing to the high incidence of mental health and addiction problems in Indigenous communities.
The Indian Act of 1876 is a piece of legislation passed in Canada in 1876. It is a piece of legislation that affects many areas of the life of First Nations members. The Indian Act was created to assimilate First Nations people into Canadian culture and relieve them of their cultural and spiritual practices (Ansloos et al., 2019). As a result, the Indian Act has had a substantial negative impact on Indigenous communities. Since it grants the government the authority to manage indigenous communities’ lands, resources, and money, the Indian Act has also been utilized to exert control over these groups.
The Sixties Scoop refers to a time in the 1960s and 1970s when Indigenous children were forcibly removed from their families and either fostered by non-Indigenous families or adopted by non-Indigenous families. This practice was known as the removal of Indigenous children. This method was implemented to “civilize” Indigenous children so they could be accepted into Canadian culture (Bingham et al., 2019). However, this led to Indigenous children losing touch with their culture and tradition, putting them at considerable risk for traumatic experiences because they were frequently abused physically, sexually, and emotionally in their foster homes. Because many of these children have reached adulthood and are passing on the repercussions of their traumatic experiences to subsequent generations, this tragedy has had a long-lasting effect on Indigenous communities.
The Indian Act and the Sixties Scoop are two examples of colonial actions that contributed to the current issue in mental health that has affected indigenous communities and caused a disruption within those communities. A high prevalence of mental illness and addiction can be seen among Indigenous communities as a direct result of the removal of their traditional methods of treatment and the trauma that indigenous people have endured as a direct result of these policies. Indigenous people have a more challenging time gaining access to the mental health services they require to heal and recover because of factors such as poverty, a lack of access to quality health care, and systemic discrimination. These factors make it more difficult for Indigenous people to heal and recover.
The Canadian residential school system is widely regarded as one of the country’s most shameful periods in its past. It began in the late 19th century and continued into the middle of the 20th century. The system intended to integrate Indigenous children into mainstream Canadian society, but the abuse, both physical and emotional, and sexual, that occurred as a result of the system was pervasive. These traumatic experiences have been handed down from one generation to the next, resulting in a cycle of intergenerational trauma that continues to hurt Indigenous communities.
Other colonial policies, such as forced deportation and the establishment of statutes and regulations that subverted traditional cultures and practices, have significantly impacted the mental health and well-being of Indigenous people, in addition to the residential school system. Indigenous communities have been left with fewer resources to address mental health and substance abuse issues as a direct result of the decline of traditional healing methods, such as religious and cultural rites and ceremonies. It has caused trauma to be passed down from generation to generation and a higher prevalence of mental health and addiction issues.
Theoretical Analysis
Intergenerational trauma is one of the main theories utilized in analyzing the issue. According to this hypothesis, the trauma and loss that Indigenous peoples endured as a result of colonization and other historical events are handed down through the generations and continue to impact the mental health and well-being of Indigenous communities today. Numerous research has found a high association between exposure to historical trauma and poor mental health outcomes, which lends credence to the idea that this theory is correct.
The cultural safety framework is yet another critical theory that was utilized in the analysis of the issue. According to this notion, providing culturally safe environments is one of the most critical factors in providing adequate mental health and addiction services to Indigenous people. It claims that mental health services must be culturally relevant, sensitive to the particular requirements of Indigenous communities, and offered in a safe, respectful, and empowering way to the individuals receiving them. Numerous research, which have shown that culturally safe care is related to superior mental health outcomes for Indigenous peoples, have lent their support to this notion.
In addition, the theory of cultural competence has been applied to research the matter. According to this school of thought, for mental health and addiction services to be useful for Indigenous peoples, they need to have a certain cultural competence. According to this theory, mental health professionals must have a comprehensive knowledge of Indigenous peoples’ cultures, traditions, and values. They also need to be able to provide care in a manner that is culturally appropriate and responsive. This notion has been validated by many studies, which have demonstrated that culturally competent care is connected with improved mental health outcomes for Indigenous peoples.
In general, there is a wealth of different theories, investigations, and points of view represented in the body of work that has been done on the issue of the mental health crisis affecting Indigenous populations. However, it is abundantly clear from the research that the ongoing impact of colonization and the loss of traditional healing practices are major contributing factors to the mental health crisis in Indigenous communities. Furthermore, cultural safety, cultural competence, and intergenerational trauma are vital concepts that need to be considered to address this crisis effectively.
Current Challenges
The inadequacy of the existing system to meet the one-of-a-kind cultural and temporal requirements of Indigenous children, adults, and families is one of the most significant obstacles that must be overcome to provide community mental health and addiction services to Indigenous communities. The existing system is not well-equipped to deal with the social and economic variables that lead to mental health and addiction issues in Indigenous communities. These factors include issues such as poverty and unemployment. Among these are poverty, a lack of access to school and career opportunities, insufficient housing and living conditions, and living standards. The current system also lacks culturally competent providers, creating a barrier for Indigenous people seeking mental health and addiction services. Moreover, the lack of culturally competent providers is a problem.
In addition, most of the facilities that make up the present system are located in metropolitan regions, which are frequently located a significant distance away from Indigenous villages and can be challenging for Indigenous people to access. This creates a significant barrier for Indigenous people seeking mental health and addiction services, particularly those living in remote or rural areas. This is especially true for those who live in rural areas.
As a result of the current system’s inadequate resources, there is a lack of confidence in the mental health and addiction programs offered by the government. This, in turn, has contributed to a lack of engagement with the current system and a reluctance to seek help for mental health and addiction issues. This presents a significant obstacle in terms of addressing the mental health crisis that is plaguing Indigenous communities. As a result, significant action is required to be taken to improve the existing system and increase access to high-quality mental health and addiction services for Indigenous people.
Currently, most treatment for mental illness and substance abuse is based on Western paradigms, which overlook the particular cultural and historical requirements of Indigenous populations. This lack of awareness and consideration leads to incorrect diagnoses of mental health and addiction difficulties and a failure to address Indigenous communities’ needs adequately. As a result, there are misdiagnoses of mental health and addiction issues.
It has been demonstrated that cultural treatments and interventions are beneficial; however, they are not always incorporated into the system that is currently in place due to a lack of knowledge and resources. The lack of utilization of culturally responsive treatments contributes to worsening the mental health crisis that affects Indigenous populations. Indigenous peoples have several barriers that prevent them from getting mental health and addiction services, including but not limited to the following: poverty, a dearth of transportation options, and social shame. Because of these roadblocks, many indigenous people cannot get the medical attention they need, worsening an already severe problem.
Numerous Indigenous communities, particularly those in remote or rural areas, face a significant challenge because they do not have adequate access to mental health and addiction treatment facilities. The indigenous people who call these locations home frequently face challenges such as extensive wait times and a dearth of access to specialist medical treatment.
Indigenous communities suffer from high rates of intergenerational trauma, mental health issues, and addiction due to colonization’s long and turbulent history, the disappearance of traditional healing practices, and the aftereffects of residential schools and other colonial policies. In addition, there has been a decline in traditional healing practices. To provide culturally responsive and effective mental health and addiction treatment, it is necessary to recognize the historical and cultural context of the mental health crisis plaguing Indigenous communities. This is necessary in order to meet the needs of Indigenous people effectively.
Positive Developments
Recognizing the vital part that cultural safety plays in successfully delivering mental health and addiction services to Indigenous communities is an essential step. In recent years, there has been a growing recognition of the need for culturally safe care to address the needs of Indigenous communities regarding mental health and addiction. This approach acknowledges the significance of considering Indigenous peoples’ cultural and historical context. It ensures that medical care is provided in a manner that is respectful, free of judgment, and individualized to meet each patient’s requirements.
Delivering healthcare services directly to urban Indigenous communities is necessary to make healthcare more accessible to urban Indigenous populations. Indigenous peoples who are living on the streets or in inadequate housing are frequently affected by mental health concerns such as depression and substance addiction while they are in metropolitan environments. Many of these people are afraid to seek medical attention at hospitals because they have had unpleasant interactions with the healthcare system. These interactions may have included painful separation from their families or racist stereotyping by medical staff. Mobile clinics associated with Indigenous community support centers could provide easily accessible emergency and addiction-related care. Indigenous peoples make up a disproportionately significant share of the homeless population in the major cities across Canada. Those trying to find a way out of homelessness may benefit from a consistent presence among these groups that considers their cultural norms. This could help them recover from substance abuse and receive mental health support and referrals to traditional healers, dentists, and other healthcare providers.
Indigenous communities have been demonstrated to benefit significantly from the progressive incorporation of indigenous healing traditions into contemporary mental health and addiction programs. There has been a growing movement, with some encouraging results, toward incorporating traditional methods of healing into conventional approaches to mental health and addiction services (George et al., 2019). This includes incorporating traditional practices such as sweat lodges, talking circles, and spiritual healing into treatment programs. These activities can help Indigenous people interact with their cultural heritage and find strength in their communities.
Incorporating cultural safety practices and traditional healing methods into mental health and addiction programs have improved outcomes and increased satisfaction levels among Indigenous populations. When culturally relevant and traditional healing modalities are integrated into mental health and addiction treatment programs, positive outcomes are seen in indigenous populations (Middleton et al., 2020). The mental health crisis facing Indigenous communities can be alleviated with the support of these methods, which have been shown to enhance mental health outcomes, decrease rates of substance addiction, and boost engagement with services.
More funding is urgently needed for mental health and addiction treatment in Indigenous communities. Money for programs that help Indigenous people with mental illness and substance abuse has grown in popularity in recent years. Access to care has been expanded, and service quality has improved. A significant increase in funding is imperative to alleviate the mental health crisis and help Indigenous people get the care they need to recover and thrive.
Increasingly, Indigenous groups are leading in designing and implementing their own culturally informed and community-based programs. Mental health and substance abuse services are already widely available, and these programs supplement those options. Some of these other programs do. Native American communities in the Pacific Northwest have had positive results from a program called “Talking Circles,” which integrates western therapy methods with traditional Indigenous healing traditions to help people cope with trauma and enhance their emotional health. The program gets its name from a Native American word for a type of treatment in which individuals meet in a group setting to discuss their problems and offer support to one another. Reducing rates of sadness and anxiety, the “Indigenous Pathways” program in Australia seeks to reacquaint Indigenous individuals with their traditional identity and community. Many believe this is because the program prioritizes helping Indigenous people reconnect with their families and neighborhoods. These programs may better serve Indigenous populations’ mental health and addiction issues by offering care and assistance tailored to their specific culture.
Conclusion
Even though there have been some encouraging developments in recent years, such as the recognition of the significance of culturally safe care, the integration of traditional healing practices, and the rise of culturally led and community-based programs, there is still a great deal of work that needs to be done in order to address the root causes of the mental health crisis that is affecting Indigenous communities. Recognizing the continued impact colonization and the disappearance of traditional healing traditions have had on the mental health of Indigenous people is paramount. When designing policies and programs to enhance the mental health and well-being of Indigenous communities, governments and service providers have a responsibility to consider this. There is a need to boost financing and support for initiatives led by cultural groups based in communities. Since these programs have been demonstrated to be effective in addressing the needs of Indigenous communities regarding mental health and addiction, they should be provided with sufficient resources to continue their work.
Increasing access to culturally sensitive and culturally competent healthcare is essential. This can be accomplished by expanding the number of Indigenous professionals working in the fields of mental health and addiction, as well as by providing training to professionals who are not Indigenous in the areas of cultural competency and the significance of cultural safety. Encouraging the level of participation of Indigenous communities in formulating and delivering mental health and addiction treatments. This can help to ensure that services are sensitive to the cultural norms of Indigenous groups and are responsive to the requirements of those communities. Taking action to address the fundamental issues that have led to the current state of mental health in Native Canadian communities, such as widespread poverty, high unemployment rates, and a dearth of access to essential resources like hospitals. If these recommendations are addressed, it is possible to achieve meaningful progress in improving the mental health and well-being of Indigenous kids, adults, and families. We can ensure that Indigenous communities have access to the care and assistance they require to lead healthy and meaningful lives if we all work together to make that happen.
References
Ansloos, J., Stewart, S., Fellner, K., Goodwill, A., Graham, H., McCormick, R., Harder, H., & Mushquash, C. (2019). Indigenous peoples and professional training in psychology in Canada. Canadian Psychology / Psychologie Canadienne, 60(4), 265–280. Web.
Bingham, B., Moniruzzaman, A., Patterson, M., Distasio, J., Sareen, J., O’Neil, J., & Somers, J. M. (2019). Indigenous and non-Indigenous people experiencing homelessness and mental illness in two Canadian cities: A retrospective analysis and implications for culturally informed action. BMJ Open, 9(4). Web.
George, J., Morton Ninomiya, M., Graham, K., Bernards, S., & Wells, S. (2019). The rationale for developing a programme of services by and for indigenous men in a First Nations community. AlterNative: An International Journal of Indigenous Peoples, 15(2), 158–167. Web.
Middleton, J., Cunsolo, A., Jones-Bitton, A., Wright, C. J., & Harper, S. L. (2020). Indigenous mental health in a changing climate: A systematic scoping review of the global literature. Environmental Research Letters, 15(5), 053001. Web.
Pride, T., Lam, A., Swansburg, J., Seno, M., Lowe, M. B., Bomfim, E., Toombs, E., Marsan, S., LoRusso, J., Roy, J., Gurr, E., LaFontaine, J., Paul, J., Burack, J. A., Mushquash, C., Stewart, S. H., & Wendt, D. C. (2021). Trauma-informed approaches to substance use interventions with indigenous peoples: A scoping review. Journal of Psychoactive Drugs, 53(5), 460–473. Web.