Introduction
The human personality is shaped by a complex web of psychological factors, ranging from early childhood experiences and family dynamics to societal and cultural influences. This intricate interplay of influences is best outlined in the character of Sascha, a 40-year-old woman suffering from anxiety, depression, and the never-ending search for a stable sense of self, in addition to acquiring fulfilling relationships. Sascha’s characterization will be examined through her family history, her reckless encounters, and her unsound relationships.
The analysis will employ different perspectives to unveil the complexity of her personality. By applying Freud’s psychoanalytic theory and Horney’s social and cultural psychoanalysis, this text seeks to disentangle the psychological basis of Sascha’s problems. Sascha’s case presents a compelling example of how childhood exposure can affect one’s emotional development.
Freud’s Psychoanalytic Theory
The rationale for choosing Freud’s Psychoanalysis Theory and Horney’s social and Cultural psychoanalysis is that these models are detailed in nature. These models are relevant to the case study because they shed light on the intricacies of human psychology. This is achieved through the prism of early life experience, the unconscious, and the interaction of social and cultural factors, all of which play a crucial role in shaping personality. These matrices are particularly valuable to Sascha because her past traumas have shaped the origins and motives of her emotional struggles and influenced her relationships. Freud’s Psychoanalytic theory posits that personality is shaped by unconscious processes, early childhood experiences, and the interplay of three components: the id, ego, and superego.
ID
According to Freud’s psychodynamic theory, the id constitutes the primitive, instinctual part of the brain that runs entirely by the pleasure principle. This condition refers to the immediate satisfaction of primary needs and the gratification of desires without fear of consequences or social norms (Spielman et al., 2021). This aspect is a fundamental part of the personality, present since birth, implying that unconscious forces drive it.
For Sascha, the id is the most significant force shaping her behavior during adolescence and the early years of adulthood. The id’s characteristics, which she demonstrates through the use of drugs and alcohol, demand immediate gratification and relief from emotional problems (Gottlieb et al., 2021). The id has many adverse effects or long-term consequences, but Sasha’s primary motivator is short-term pleasure.
For example, Sascha’s addiction to drugs and alcohol can be regarded as an attempt to blank out her family dysfunction, including pain and anxiety. Being raised in an environment dominated by parental negligence, abuse, and alcohol, Sascha felt emotional and was deprived of healthy ways to deal with her negative feelings. Her id-centered behaviors can be seen as attempts to get rid of her mental problems, though these methods are destructive in the future. Additionally, Sascha’s id-driven behaviors may be an attempt to regulate her emotions and help her overcome the barriers she faces.
Ego
The ego, the core part of Freud’s psychoanalytic concept, evolves from the id and works according to the principle of reality. Distinguished from the id, which instantly wants to pursue satisfaction without regard for the consequences of such acts, the ego moderates the actions and desires of the id, the limitations and rules of reality, and the ethical guidelines of the superego (Harvey, n.d.). It is the rational part of the mind interested in preserving an equilibrium between the demands of instinctive drives and the acceptance of societal Rules. In Sascha’s case, her problems maintaining relationships and her lack of emotional connection reveal her ego functioning with great clarity.
As a mediator of interpersonal dynamics, the ego is influenced by two powerful forces from her id and superego regarding the relationships she desires and the level of emotional intimacy she is willing to share. Sascha’s inability to establish long-lasting, deep, and meaningful relationships indicates inner strife and subconscious pressures that the ego confronts as it struggles with incompatible needs (Spielman et al., 2021). In contrast, her id may lead her to seek immediate pleasure and excitement, even in relationships (Gottlieb et al., 2021).
Instantly, her decisions become impulsive, and her relations become unstable. However, her superego can be strict about emotional closeness and commitment standards, and Sascha may fail to meet those demands. For instance, her choosing a less cold-hearted boy is proof of her yearning for greater emotional sharing and bonding, values similar to those dictated by her conscience.
Superego
In implying moral norms, values, and guiding principles that a person learns from their parents and peer group, the superego is a significant component of Freud’s psychoanalysis. According to Spielman et al. (2021), the superego is the driving force of the unconscious, assessing actions as right or wrong and dictating behavior through decision-making rules. Sascha’s urge for emotional closeness and her craving for new connections with others are the result of the extremes between her impulses and her id, and of how her superego positions itself. The superego permeates interpersonal relationships and intimacy, internalizing the moral values embedded in cultural norms that a person learns during development (Harvey, n.d.). Sascha might start to compare her current boyfriend to her ex and see him as emotionally distant, which may profoundly affect her feelings and guilt.
In addition, the unhappy situation she is currently in may stem from the values and messages she received in childhood about love, intimacy, and satisfaction. As the best standard ever for Sascha, the superego should adopt the best ideals at the moment she grew up without figures of supportive, healthy relationships or role models (Gottlieb et al., 2021). On the other hand, Sascha’s id-directed impulses usually stem from emotion, and seeking a partner in conflict with her superego’s moral canon of natural love relations. The internal conflict in the Sascha character manifests as guilt, inadequacy, and frustration as she struggles to reconcile her instinctive desires with her moral standards.
Horney’s Social and Cultural Psychoanalysis
Horney’s psychoanalysis provides a perspective through which social and cultural factors can directly influence personality formation, with primary emphasis on the basic need for security and the importance of early relations. Horney’s idea of Basic Anxiety touches on the core of the existence of feelings of helplessness and insecurity originating in the earliest relationships that can turn into recurrent anxiety as people try to escape it through various means (Tarzian et al.,2023).
Sascha’s case provides a poignant illustration of how this theory plays out in real life. In Horney’s opinion, the underlying cause of Basic Anxiety is childhood trauma (Mirahsani & Norouzi, 2023; Tarzian et al.,2023). The anxiety and uncertainty resulting from these associations are the primary reasons why members of the family unit may not always get what they are supposed to have in terms of proper care.
Sascha’s growing up in a pathological family with disregardful parents, abuse, and alcoholism had a multitude of characteristics in common with the conditions that are favorable for the development of Basic Anxiety. According to Tarzian et al. (2023), basic anxiety is evident when children grow up in an emotionally neglectful environment. The constant changes and challenges that Sasha faced resulted in unstable emotions of powerlessness, insecurity, and anxiety as a child.
Moreover, Sascha’s family situation, with parental neglect and abuse, most likely brought about a sense of deep insecurity and powerlessness. Without emotional support and stability, which are children’s basic needs at this stage of their development, they cannot thrive. Sascha may have felt unloved and unworthy and tried to prove to others that she was not weak and could not be hurt.
Neuroses can be observed through the fact that Saschahas apparent difficulties with healthy ways of coping, as demonstrated by her risky conduct, for example, substance and alcohol abuse, and her involvement in unstable relations. These neuroses are efforts aimed at making her anxiety less severe and oppressive (Tarzian et al., 2023). Wang et al. (2023) discuss how individuals engage in substance abuse as a means of coping with life challenges. Sascha may succeed in escaping the emotional suffering and need for affection from her loved ones through the use of substances. To escape the persistent sense of insecurity about her existence, she turns to these behaviors, which are just momentary solutions.
The other reason for Sascha’s quick pursuit of friendships could be her looking for the emptiness within herself and seeking validation and approval from the outside world. The quest for belonging and hope is why Sascha slowly turns to the kinds of connections in his life that offer only an instant of being embraced. However, nothing addresses the immediate nagging insecurities that keep driving the actions.
From Horney’s perspective, neurotic needs or how to meet them are how people seek to cope with a subconscious fear, as well as the lack of self-respect and self-esteem. Consequently, these needs are nothing more than tactics to elicit feelings of adoration, security, and completeness from others (Tarzian et al., 2023). Sascha’s issues can be interpreted as a vivid illustration of the brain’s desire to find an emotional connection at any cost, followed by the need for affirmation. Tarzian et al. (2023) contend that individuals are driven to seek out neurotic needs to cope with inner-state tension and intensity. Seeking external validation and recognition is one of the common ways people try to forget about their deep-rooted feelings of not being worthy or significant.
Sascha’s deeply disappointing attitude towards the current relationship demonstrates her inner yearning for an emotional connection and gaining approval. While having someone who can emotionally support Sascha might be a good option, she grew up in a place without children. As Fitzgerald et al. (2020) indicate, those emotionally distant from their parents during childhood will seek validation in other ways. She would eventually develop a perpetual need for verification and confirmation from others in the company to fill the void she felt she was less worthy of.
In addition, Sascha’s frequent and rapid swapping from one relationship to another, as if she were looking for someone genuine and stable, is a reliable probe of her neurosis. In their endless emotional disorder, Saschas pursue one relationship after another in the hope of receiving an ultimate object of fiction – a knock of recognition. On the other hand, her extreme reliance on external sources leads to a perpetual, futile search for attachment. However, if not satisfied, she ends up creating havoc, since one relationship is used to address an unmet personal need.
Effects of Past Experiences and Family Settings
The process of Sascha’s personality formation is intricately intertwined with all her past experiences and her family’s dynamics, each of which is a meritorious trait that shapes her ethos, demeanor, and emotional health. Ahn et al. (2016) and Kubeka (2008) explore the effects of childhood exposure and cultural background on their development. Sascha’s background has a lasting impact on her mindset, personality, and relationships with others. Sascha’s father’s alcoholism and physically abusive behavior left their mark on her psychological and emotional development. They set a pattern of behavior that affected her sense of safety and trust in her relatedness with others.
Silvén Hagström and Forinder (2022) offer compelling examples of the impact of alcoholic families on children as they grow up. Sascha’s affinity to her neighborhood, where chaos, violence, and emotional confusion predominated, resulted in learned characteristics of fear, incapacity to trust, and feeling insecure. The intolerable presence of his father’s alcoholism and abuse manifested in the continuous state of uneasiness and fear that became the background of Sascha’s everyday life. Her father’s unpredictable behavior must have made her feel as if she were on constant alert, not knowing when the next unexpected outburst would come.
Sascha’s relationship with her father could have severely affected her trust in others, leading her to approach relationships carefully and somewhat skeptically. Sascha’s experience of betrayal can explain her reluctance to share her problems with others, as she fears similar pain or disappointment. Adem (2021) offers compelling examples of how the absence of emotional support affects children’s development.
Drawing on Adem’s (2021) views, it can be asserted that Sascha’s mother’s unappreciated absence from her life worsened the situation, leaving her feeling abandoned and irrelevant. Without the maternal figure caring for her and matching her voice’s sounds, tone, and rhythm, Sascha may have had difficulty establishing a solid foundation for self-worth and identity. Sascha’s mother’s emotional absence led her to believe that everyone in her family was only concerned with themselves.
Her sense of insignificance was exacerbated by comparisons with the astounding success of her principal siblings, thereby magnifying her feeling of inadequacy. According to Hamwey and Whiteman (2021), children may feel neglected and rejected when one child is praised over others, as this can lead to envy. Her frequent references to her siblings’ achievements may have further reinforced her negative thoughts about her own abilities, ultimately influencing her life and decision-making. Another factor that may have caused the change in Sascha’s behavioral and decision-making model is the family structure in which she was raised. Sascha may have found herself in a situation in which she had to compete for recognition.
Other Theoretical Perspectives
Adler’s Individual Psychology
Adler’s Individual Psychology offers another understanding of personality development, emphasizing the yearning for greatness and the need to overcome a sense of inferiority. Sascha’s experiences of being hidden behind her siblings and her difficulties in finding a genuine connection can be analyzed using this idea. Adler stipulates that striving for superiority comes from the psychological need to contend with feelings of inferiority (Ferguson, 2020). Adler, like Horney, believed that childhood environment significantly contributes to their emotional development (Ferguson, 2020). Sascha’s childhood, in which she lacked her parents’ attention and felt left out as her siblings achieved success, might have led her to feel an internal need to demonstrate that she, too, has a purpose and the ability to achieve success as they did.
Sascha’s willingness to fight for a more satisfactory relationship may be her response to the feelings she thinks she possesses. Freud argued that people can self-actualize through aggressive urges, while Adler argued that feelings of childhood inferiority drive people to strive to become superior (Damianova et al., 2016; Gaines Jr., 2020; Ryckman, 2012). Adler would analyze how Sascha’s lack of confidence and inability to compete with her siblings drove her to seek acceptance and recognition from her relationships (Ferguson, 2020). However, her involvement in such activities may also fill her inner emptiness by creating an illusion of power or a sensation of excitement.
Adler emphasizes that individuals have subjective experiences before developing misconceptions about a particular situation. In Sascha’s case, Adler would examine her personal history to understand how experiences from her childhood and family relationships shaped her views, ideas, and behaviors (Ferguson, 2020). Adlerian therapy considers Sascha’s perceptions to guide her in recognizing her inadequate feelings and in developing alternative coping strategies that will help her build her self-esteem and confidence.
Bandura’s Social Learning Theory
Bandura’s Social Learning Theory assumes the established role of observational learning and modeling in personality development. Ryckman (2012) offers a compelling overview of personality theories, including Bandura’s social learning model. While Horney and Freud focused on how the environment shapes behavior, Bandura added the insight that learning also occurs through observing how others behave and the rewards they receive or punishments they face (Hancock et al., 2024).
Bandura postulates that people acquire experience through self-observation and the consequences they encounter in their environment (Hancock et al., 2024). Sascha could have acquired harmful traits, for example, engaging in drug and alcohol use, after observing such behaviors among her family members. Bandura stresses the significance of role models and significant others in shaping behavior (Hamedi et al., 2021). Sascha’s mind might have been shaped by her parents and siblings, who positively influenced her relationship patterns and attitude toward risk-taking.
Conclusion
Schasca’s personality and behavioral problems, as demonstrated through struggles with emotions and interpersonal relationships, can be illustrated using different theoretical methods, as every aspect of her personality is examined. Each theory brings a particular point of view, whether the stress of the inner process in Freud’s elaboration or Horney’s attention to the social and cultural environment. More models, such as Adler, who discusses lower-class instincts—which arise after an individual’s grounding feeling of inferiority—and Bandura, who states that childhood is vital for maturation, are important concepts to consider. The different theories of psychology introduced not only address the underlying causes of Sascha’s struggles but also the options for dealing with these problems holistically through the individual customization of therapeutic techniques.
References
Adem, S. S. (2021). Maternal absence and transnational female labour migration; Implications for the left-behind child. International Journal of Migration, Health and Social Care, 17(3), 315-336.
Ahn, H. S., Usher, E. L., Butz, A., & Bong, M. (2016). Cultural differences in the understanding of modelling and feedback as sources of self-efficacy information. British Journal of Educational Psychology, 86(1), 112–136.
Damianova, M., Deacon, E., Foxcroft, C., & Nicholas. L.J. (2016). Personality psychology. Oxford University Press Southern Africa.
Ferguson, E. D. (2020). Adler’s motivational theory: An historical perspective on belonging and the fundamental human striving. The Journal of Individual Psychology, 76(1), 51-58.
Fitzgerald, M., Hamstra, C., & Ledermann, T. (2020). Childhood maltreatment and adult’s provisions of emotional support given to family, friends, and romantic partners: An examination of gender differences. Child Abuse & Neglect, 106.
Gaines Jr, S. (2020). Personality Psychology: The basics. Routledge.
Gottlieb, T., Furnham, A., & Klewe, J. B. (2021). Personality in the light of identity, reputation and role taking: A review of socioanalytic theory. Psychology, 12(12), 2020-2041.
Hamedi, F., Pashaei Fakhri, K., & Adelzadeh, P. (2021). A psychoanalytic study of two Iranian Novels based on Albert Bandura’s theory of cognitive-social learning. Iranian Journal of Comparative Education, 4(4), 1479-1496.
Hamwey, M. K., & Whiteman, S. D. (2021). Jealousy links comparisons with siblings to adjustment among emerging adults. Family Relations, 70(2), 483-497.
Hancock, D. J., & Rymal, A. M. (2024). Sport officials’ use of observational learning. Frontiers in Sports and Active Living, 6.
Harvey, F. (n.d.). Present and critically assess the main contributions of Freud’s theory of personality to sociological analysis, The Undergraduate Journal of Psychology, 22(16). 16-22.
Kubeka, A. (2008). Exposure to violence at home: A qualitative exploration of experiences and perceptions of black adolescents in South Africa. South African Review of Sociology, 39(2), 282-300.
Mirahsani, L., & Norouzi, M. (2023). A psychoanalytical analysis of Anton Chekhov’s the Darling and Anyuta in the light of Karen Horney’s theory of moving toward people [In English]. Journal of Studies in Applied Language (JSAL), 6(2), 17-40.
Ryckman, R. (2012). Theories of personality (10th ed.). Cengage Learning.
Silvén Hagström, A., & Forinder, U. (2022). ‘If I whistled in her ear she’d wake up‘: Children’s narration about their experiences of growing up in alcoholic families. Journal of Family Studies, 28(1), 216-238.
Spielman, R. M., Dumper, K., Jenkins, W., Lacombe, A., Lovett, M., & Perlmutter, M. (2021). Freud and the psychodynamic perspective. Pressbooks.
Tarzian, M., Ndrio, M., & Fakoya, A. O. (2023). An introduction and brief overview of psychoanalysis. Cureus, 15(9).
Wang, C. D., Anderson-White, E., & Jin, L. (2022). Adult attachment, maladaptive coping, alcohol consumption, and drinking-related problems. Counselling Psychology Quarterly, 35(1), 43-60.