Introduction
The powerful forces of colonialism and globalization have attracted the attention of scholars and historians since they have continued to transform people’s cultural practices, beliefs, and norms. The wave of modernism compelled Islamic leaders and teachers to present revolutionary ideas intended to reconcile the faith with most of the emerging values. With the West promoting a wide range of concepts centered on Christianity, followers of Islam would find themselves at a crossroads.
Such trends would compel these believers to reexamine their views and religious texts from a critical perspective. More believers would start to consider the best ways to reinterpret existing teachings and apply them accordingly in the modern world. Despite the divergent paths associated with Islamic modernism, the process has continued to rely on the religion’s traditional faith while accepting specific values, ideologies, and sociological perspectives related to European culture.
Background and Research Question
Different European nations relied on the forces of colonialism to acquire resources for their industries, achieve their imperialistic aims, and spread Christianity. In the Islamic world, the majority of the people realized that the emerging foreign ideals were opposed to their religious beliefs. The concept of capitalism was unrealistic and incapable of supporting most of their cultural goals.
Local leaders were concerned that the continuous promotion of such values could undermine Islam’s integrity. Consequently, the majority of Muslims and their respective teachers reacted to all ideas of colonialism in the 19th century. These actions would play a critical role in rewriting the history of the Islamic world.
The emerging movement in Muslim societies would play a positive role in fighting imperialism and reforming the Islamic faith. This effort will make it possible for more Islamic societies to overcome the challenge of the West. Historians and analysts have defined this kind of movement as Islamic reformism. This movement has continued to influence the social and political attributes of most of these Muslim countries. The outcome would be the emergence of different religious subgroups and organizations characterized by different orientations and interpretations.
The completed study sought to examine the roots of Islamic reformism. The analysis provided a detailed overview of the movement’s historical context and some of the identifiable figures. The study managed to demonstrate how unity within Islam has remained a unique attribute characterized by diversity among Muslims. This phenomenon is notable in a wide range of modernist trends, which challenge traditional attributes while at the same time affirming allegiance to the major core principles of Islam.
Some of them are God’s Oneness and the prophethood of Muhammad. The exploration of the highlighted ideas played a significant role in learning more about the complexities associated with Arab-Muslim identities. The research question for this study was: What are the impacts of the Islamic reformist movement on the modern Islamic world and the diversity of its notable identities?
Research Statement
The presence of diverse Arab Muslim identities in different parts of the world is an issue that has received little interest among scholars and religious historians. To learn more about these cultural groups, researchers should focus on Islamic reformism and the great figures behind the movement. Despite the complexities among contemporary Arab Muslims, a sense of unity exists among these individuals.
Brown acknowledges that modernist trends remained opposed to traditional values, while most believers pronounced their allegiance to the basic tenets of Islam. These include Muhammad’s prophethood and the Oneness of God. By completing an additional study, it is possible to get a clearer understanding of reformist movements recorded in the Islamic world and how they helped transform the modern world. The study would go further to examine and describe the diversity of contemporary Muslim identities.
Historical Contexts of Islam and Modernism
Ottoman Empire
The success and progress of Islam are largely attributable to the achievements of the Ottoman Empire from the 13th century. Suleiman the Magnificent’s able leadership was critical since it made it possible for the region to record unprecedented economic, social, and governmental developments. The Ottomans engaged in numerous conquests that led to the collapse of the Byzantine Empire in the mid-15th century.
Having replaced the Byzantine Empire, the regions in the East of the Mediterranean would experience new ideologies characterized by Islamic institutions and ideas. The promotion of Islam as the empire’s official religion ensured that caliphates occupied the highest religious positions. The promoted policies required Sultans to practice and remain devout Muslims.
The leaders appointed at the time were expected to remain professional and respectful of their states. They had to accept and pursue their actions and thoughts in accordance with the teachings of Islam. Additionally, their behaviors, language, and cultural practices were influenced by Islamic principles.
During that time, the Ottomans would allow Christians and Jews to live amongst them since they appreciated the idea of extending religious beliefs. However, such faiths had to be performed in such a way that they were acceptable, legal, and valid. These trends and impacts of the Ottoman Empire played a significant role in defining the future of Islam in the Arab world.
Napoleon: Turning Point for the Colonial Edge
Napoleon Bonaparte remains one of the most celebrated and widely studied military leaders whose actions changed the world forever. During his reign, Napoleon initiated numerous social, political, and liberal reforms that would play a crucial role in making the global community better for more people. Following several battles between the French and various regions within the Ottoman Empire, the leader would influence the restoration of liberties and rights while setting the stage for renewed diplomatic agreements and relations.
Napoleon relied further on his influence to support the establishment of new routes and markets in Russia and the Persian region. After his successful visit to various Arab regions in the early 19th century, he was keen to transform the lifestyles of the people by introducing the benefits of Western civilization. During the French campaigns of 1798 to 1802, Napoleon was able to identify new markets while defending the established trade interests. These achievements made it possible for the French to launch their scientific ambitions in the Arab world. Consequently, such activities paved the way for the continued struggle and partition of the region by different European powers.
British Colonization
The events surrounding the exploration and conquests by Napoleon opened up the Arab region to the world, thereby promoting political and economic exchange. However, such a development would become a major opportunity for European powers, such as Britain, to identify and colonize various regions across the Arab world and North Africa. To ensure that positive results were recorded in the Middle East, British troops collaborated with Ottoman leaders to evict the French from different key areas, such as Egypt.
The British chose to balance their economic interests and strategic ambitions. While colonialism in the Middle East was characterized by collaboration, events towards the end of the 19th century compelled the British to reconsider their strategies. These efforts would be instrumental in the country’s involvement in the First World War.
After successfully controlling most of the factors of production, natural resources, oil, trade routes, and economic activities, the British colonizers went further to impose additional ideologies. Specifically, they focused on elements that had the potential to transform the people’s culture through the wave of modernity. These efforts would play a significant role in fragmenting the people’s social fabric and attributes.
The British applied unique tactics intended to challenge the teachings of Islam and the customs of the locals. The European powers strongly believed that most Islamic values were inappropriate and incapable of promoting civilization. Consequently, colonial leaders engaged in teachings and efforts specifically intended to reject Islamic practices and beliefs that had been pursued for hundreds of years.
Challenges
Colonization as an Ideology
The colonization of the Middle East is a strong case study that shows how foreigners introduced and promoted a new ideology against the people’s wishes. The emerging ideas and teachings would leave an indelible mark on the cultural values and practices of Muslims. Ali indicates that colonialism became an unexpected force that imposed foreign laws, economic models, education systems, and notions that were alien to the people.
The colonialists promoted Christian-based ideas in a society that followed Islam. This form of ideology compelled people to examine how they could pursue their individualistic interests without considering the plight of their relatives. More European powers would deliver similar ideas while remaining mindful of their ambitions.
Supremacy of Reason over Tradition
Having experienced the fruits of the French Revolution and other social changes in Europe, most of these colonial powers believed strongly that the time to promote reason over tradition had come. They would promote similar ideas in their respective colonies by encouraging most of their subjects to ignore the teachings and notions associated with their cultural practices. For Muslims, the wave of colonization would introduce foreign social, economic, and spiritual attributes that differed significantly from their traditions. The majority of the foreigners introduced debates that touched on the concepts of modernization and the importance of secular subjects. These new ideas presented a cultural dilemma since most of the Muslim believers were unable to get rid of their traditions and values.
Industrialization and Its Economic Impact
During the colonial period, most Middle Eastern countries acquired new ideas that were critical for supporting industrialization. The presence and importance of oil in the region became a new reality during and after the First World War. These foreigners introduced Western ideas that made it possible for most countries to experience positive economic impacts. This foreign influence will encourage more leaders to strike a balance between traditional views and modern ways of promoting economic performance. They would consider such developments while remaining mindful of their religious ideologies and backgrounds.
Modernity
From the mid-20th century, most of the countries in the Arab world gained independence from their colonial masters. The departure of these powers made it possible for local leaders to engage in activities and policymaking processes that led to the modernization of the states. Some of the notable developments included the growth and subsequent positive performance of the region’s petroleum industry. Additionally, the leaders ensured that Islam’s fundamental beliefs and teachings continued to dictate the people’s behaviors and practices. By rejecting most of the attributes associated with the West, most of these countries pursued modernistic ideas while ensuring that religion dominated people’s notions about social statuses, opportunities, rights, and goals.
Diverse Thinking
Modernized Islam practiced today is characterized by divergent thoughts and ideologies that define its identity. This scenario exists because some religious leaders in different regions examined most of the emerging foreign influences and merged them with the traditional teachings of Islam. Due to colonialism’s influences and impacts, different schools of Islamic thought emerged that have continued to dictate the social, political, and economic aspects that most countries experience today. Some of the thinkers and their diverse ideologies are presented below.
Syed Ahmed Khan
As a famous Islamic scholar, Syed Ahmed Khan is credited with promoting a new form of education that borrowed a number of Western ideologies and concepts. He advocated for a new school of thought whereby Indian Muslims could embrace modernity and use scientific inquiry to interpret the Quran. He believed strongly that the Muslim community needed to promote the idea of global reformation to integrate the region with the rest of the world.
To support his agenda, Khan engaged in social causes that he intended to uplift the lives of poor citizens. He recognized the relevance of modern education since it was capable of promoting social reforms and allowing more people to transform their experiences. The influence would play a crucial role in supporting a wide range of nation-building efforts in India.
Muhammad Abduh Jamal
As a great religious scholar, Muhammad Abduh believed that the time had come for Muslims to start reinterpreting religious texts in a way that focused on the issues of the time. He supported the use of knowledge since it would promote a sense of independence and the power of reasoning.
While he remained opposed to the Western way of doing things, Abdul discouraged his followers from returning to the ancient ways of Islam. Instead, he wanted them to reinterpret the Quran in a civilized and genuine manner. For example, he indicated that polygamy could be avoided if it could trigger injustice in Muslim families. He remained opposed to different forms of racial discrimination. By pursuing such an interest in religion, Abduh believed that most Arab communities would find it easier to get rid of Western imperialism, characterized by secular ideals. Consequently, the teaching of the Quran would make it possible for more people to get rid of their social, economic, and political predicaments.
Jamal al-Din al-Afghani
In his works, this political activist and religious influencer focused on the importance of strengthening Islamic institutions by borrowing a lot from Western ideologies. According to him, such an approach would allow those in leadership to identify attributes that would strengthen the religion while minimizing British domination. He wanted all patriotic religious leaders to remain strong and embrace modernity to advance the region. He encouraged people to ignore the differences recorded in the existing Islamic jurisprudence and think deeper to present a coordinated and united response to the emerging Western influence.
Muhammad Iqbal
In his works, poems, and lectures, Muhammad Iqbal explained the importance of pursuing Islam as a religion capable of promoting modern legal, social, and political philosophies. He believed that most of the politicians of his time remained immoral and misguided. He believed that a political arrangement characterized by religious tolerance and cooperation was essential for promoting social order. He guided Muslims to avoid drawing lines and instead think of unity among all Muslims, irrespective of their religious thoughts. The important objective was to support a Muslim population brought together by Islamic teachings and principles.
The Impact of Modernism on Islam
Present
In the present world, modernism continues to remain a powerful force that influences Islam. Jung indicates that followers of the religion are constantly responding to the cultural trends and challenges recorded in the West. Individuals have been compelled to appreciate modern values and integrate them within the teachings of the Quran. For example, Islamic communities have been keen to embrace notions of equality, progress, and civil rights.
Leaders are engaging in reflections in an effort to invent a new approach to Islamic theology. Many countries in the Middle East continue to promote ideas that guide people to promote their faiths while expressing themselves adequately in their lives. Religious leaders have been keen to consider issues related to gender and empowerment in an effort to support all believers. Modernism remains a powerful force that has been influencing most of the described changes.
Future
While Muslims have been compelled to appreciate the forces of modernism, some believers continue to promote a traditionalist approach to the religion. This scenario explains why different Islamic movements and responses have been recorded in different parts of the world. Leaders are expected to be torn between tolerance and moderation in the future.
Other religious groups would be concerned about the forces of modernism and how they could combat the problematic issues of terrorism, extremism, and violence. In the future, more Muslims might be compelled to find new ways of examining the challenge of Islamophobia and the manner in which cooperation could be realized. Additionally, followers of Islam would be compelled to continue finding new ways of merging their thoughts and reinterpreting the Quran to integrate the trends triggered by modernism.
Conclusion
The long history of Islam reveals how the Ottoman Empire played a critical role in supporting the establishment of respectable institutions and cultural values influenced by the Quran. Napoleon Bonaparte’s expeditions opened up the region to colonialism and subsequent changes in religious ideologies. Most of the famous scholars and activists of the time guided more followers to modernize the religion and consider how they could industrialize their countries. These trends would result in a diversified society whereby the people would practice religion in such a way that the emerging values and practices resonated with the changes recorded in the world today. Based on this past, chances are high that future religious leaders will consider how they could cooperate with the West, address extremism, and tackle the challenge of Islamophobia.
References
Abbasi, Muhammad U. “Impacts of Multiple Global Thoughts on Islamic Culture and Civilization: Academician Response by Muslim Scholars.” lkogretim Online – Elementary Education Online 19, no. 4 (2020): 4600-4608.
Accad, Martin, and Jonathan Andrews, eds. The Religious Other: A Biblical Understanding of Islam, the Qur’an, and Muhammad. London: Langham Global Library, 2020.
Ali, Jan A. “Modernity, Its Crisis and Islamic Revivalism.” Religions 14, no. 1 (2023): 15-39.
Brown, Daniel W. A New Introduction to Islam. 3rd ed. New York: Wiley Blackwell, 2017.
Hasan, Mohammad. “Sir Syed Ahmad Khan and his Contributions: An Essay.” International Journal for Innovative Research in Multidisciplinary Field 8, no. 2 (2022): 8-10.
Hussain, Ishtiaq. “Revisiting a Fractured Legacy: Sir Syed Ahmed Khan and Muslim Women’s Education.” Rashhat-e-Qalam 2, no. 2 (2022): 85-100.
Jung, Dietrich. “Islamism, Islamic Modernism and the Search for Modern Authenticity in an Imaginary Past”. Religions 12, no. 11 (2021): 1005-1017.
Khames, Ahmed. “The Impact of the Mental Tendency of the Mutazilites in the Verbal Opinions of Jamal al-Din al-Afghani (1897 AD) and Muhammad Abdo (d. 1905 AD).” Journal of Scientific Research in Arts 23, no. 6 (2022): 65-83.
Murata, Sachiko, and William Chittick. The Vision of Islam. St. Paul: Paragon House, 1994.
Popp, Stephan. “Muhammad Iqbal – Reconstructing Islam along Occidental Lines of Thought.” Interdisciplinary Journal for Religion and Transformation in Contemporary Society 5, no. 1 (2019): 201–229.